• Marathon Science
  • Posts
  • Why VO2 Max Isn’t the Race-Day Hero You Think It Is—Here’s When It Actually Matters and How to Train It for Peak Results

Why VO2 Max Isn’t the Race-Day Hero You Think It Is—Here’s When It Actually Matters and How to Train It for Peak Results

Why VO₂ Max Isn’t the Race-Day Hero You Think It Is—Here’s When It Actually Matters and How to Train It for Peak Results

Estimated read time: 3.38 minutes (just enough time for your Garmin to overestimate your fitness again). 😉

Hey Performance Nerds! Jonah here. 🤓

99% of runners are chasing a bigger VO2 max, thinking it's the key to faster times. Not so fast.

Most races happen below your VO2 max. You’re building a Ferrari engine but only driving it at 75%.

Even elites don’t win on VO₂ max alone. Paula Radcliffe, British marathon icon, kept getting faster even though her VO₂ max stayed the same. Her edge?

She ran more efficiently—faster pace, same oxygen.

Today we're breaking down:

  • 😱 Why your VO₂ max ceiling doesn’t dictate race pace

  • 🤔 When VO₂ max actually matters (and when it doesn’t)

  • A science-backed progression that actually works

  • 📊 My go-to 6-week training block for aerobic upgrades

(Augie, my dog, still wants a Ferrari just to hang his tongue out the window at 100 mph.)

🧬 Performance Sponsor:

🚀 Train Harder. Recover Smarter. Save 15%.

SiS—the same science-backed fuel trusted by Olympic marathoners—is now sponsoring Marathon Science.

From hydration mixes to recovery tools, every product is backed by real performance data and built for serious athletes like you.

🎯 Use code JONAH15 for 15% off at The Feed
🕒 Only available until July 15
🛒 One-time use per customer—don’t miss your chance to stock up.

🧠 What VO2 Max Really Means (and Why It’s Not Race Pace)

VO₂ max is your aerobic engine’s horsepower—how much oxygen you can use at full throttle.

But here’s what your Garmin won’t say: you don’t race at full throttle.

  • Marathon pace? 75–85% of VO₂ max

  • HYROX? ~80–90%

  • Even 5Ks? Maybe 95% at best

🏃‍♂️ VO₂ max and marathon pace: About as far apart as me and Augie (my dog) after a heated debate over where to order Uber Eats. We stay far away from each other. 🐕🍕

Big engines are great—but races are won on efficiency, not redline.

(Okay fine... redlining a Ferrari is fun. Augie agrees.)

⚡ When VO₂ Max IS the Bottleneck

VO₂ max starts to matter when your threshold and race paces are already near it.

Think of it like this:

  • VO₂ max = ceiling

  • Threshold & Race Pace = floors

When the floors are almost touching the ceiling, it’s time to raise the roof! 🏠 (Shoutout to Phil Skiba for the perfect analogy.)

Raising your VO₂ max creates space to move your threshold and race pace up!

Signs your VO₂ max might be the limiter:

  • Your 5K and Half paces are nearly identical

  • Your times have flatlined despite consistent training

  • Speedwork leaves you gasping—or dreading the workout

  • Training partners with similar long-run times drop you on short reps

🗓 Periodization: When to Train VO2 Max (and When to Chill)

VO₂ max sessions belong early in the training cycle—before sharpening race-specific gears.

This raises your aerobic ceiling early—so you’ve got room to boost threshold and race pace later when it counts most.

Here’s the ideal flow:

  • Weeks 16–12: Base mileage + aerobic work, with VO₂ intervals sprinkled in

  • Weeks 12–8: VO₂ takes a backseat; threshold work ramps up

  • Weeks 8–4: Prioritize race pace sessions for efficiency

  • Weeks 4–0: Taper and sharpen—keep fitness, lose fatigue

🧠 Why it works:

  • VO₂ max gains stick with maintenance

  • Threshold and race paces need fresh practice closer to race day

🏋️ The Gold-Standard VO2 Max Protocol

Want to build a bigger aerobic engine? Don’t just go hard—go smart.

Research shows the best VO₂ max gains come from hitting 90% of your VO₂ max for controlled intervals:

🔬 The formula:

  • 2–3 sessions/week

  • 30 second–8 min intervals

  • Equal work-to-rest ratio

  • 5–20 total interval minutes/session

Think of it like short, focused redlines—these sessions put your cardiovascular system under high strain long enough to drive meaningful adaptation.

⚠️ These are high fatigue cost. Don’t skip easy days. Recovery isn’t optional—it’s the secret sauce.

📊 6-Week VO₂ Max Block Progression

This protocol blends intervals, threshold runs, and hills to boost both aerobic power and efficiency—without burnout.

🎯 Practical Summary: VO2 Max 101

  • VO₂ max matters if threshold is already >85% of VO₂ max

  • Train it early in the season (4–6 week blocks)

  • Use 3–8 min intervals @ 90–95% HR, 2–3x/week

  • Maintain gains with 1 session every 2–3 weeks

💬 One last thing before you go.

After the NFL, I wasn’t sure if obsessing over performance science still mattered—until I started helping this community.

Your training goals? They brought that fire back.

So if you're feeling stuck, second-guessing something, or just want to share how training's going—hit reply. I read every message, and I’m here to help however I can.

🚨 The truth about lowering your heart rate during zone 2 runs 👇

Did you miss my post about The truth about lowering your heart rate during zone 2 runs 👇? You can find it below!

I won’t lie. These videos take me a while to make. If you find it helpful, share it on your story or with a friend. It helps me a ton!

Are You a True Running Nerd? Prove it.. 🧐

Welcome to the prove you’re a nerd section. Each week, I ask a question about a common running science myth.

Answer correctly, and you’ll be entered into a weekly raffle to win a package of Jonah’s favorite supplements.

What’s the most effective way to build strength without wrecking your recovery as a runner? 🏋️‍♂️💨

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Last Week’s Results: Sodium Science Unpacked 🧂💧

Heads up, hydration nerds—this one sparked a mini salt-storm. So let’s clear it up: I take electrolytes daily and recommend them to every athlete I coach. But during races? Timing is everything.

The correct answer?
C. When exercise exceeds 4 hours, it's hot, and you're replacing most of your sweat losses 

That’s where the science kicks in—specifically, from sodium researcher Alan McCubbin. His research shows that:

  • For shorter events (like sub 3 marathons or soccer matches), sodium replacement isn’t necessary, even with high sweat rates.

  • The body can maintain sodium levels naturally—especially if you're only replacing ~60–70% of your fluid losses.

  • Sodium only becomes critical in ultra-long events where you’re drinking a lot and sweating buckets (think: 4+ hours in the heat). In those cases, failing to replace sodium could lead to hyponatremia (dangerously low blood sodium).

Vote Breakdown:
🟩 A. Any time you start sweating—even in short workouts – 118 votes
⬜️ B. Only during intense interval training sessions – 9 votes
🟨 C. When exercise exceeds 4 hours, it's hot you're replacing most of your sweat losses – 38 votes
⬜️ D. Only if you have low sodium in your diet to begin with – 17 votes

Bottom line?
Electrolytes matter—a lot—but they’re not a magic bullet during every session. Use them daily for hydration habits and pre/post fueling. In racing, their performance impact shows up most during long, hot, high-fluid events. So don’t skip the sodium—but time it wisely. 💧🧠

Want the full geek-out? McCubbin’s research found that even in hot marathons, sodium isn’t required unless you're over-replacing fluid and sweating like crazy. Cramping? That’s usually about fitness, not salt.

Let’s science smarter—not salt harder. 🧂📊

Nerdy Finds of the Week 📚🧑‍🔬

This section includes my favorite research, podcasts or books about running/lifting science.

Research Review: Alan McCubbin’s Sodium Research

🔬 Core Finding

  • Sodium replacement is only needed in ultra-endurance events if you’re drinking enough to replace 70%+ of sweat losses.

📊 Key Research Points

  • Plasma sodium stayed stable in marathons—even with high sweat sodium and no sodium intake

  • Hyponatremia risk only appeared when athletes drank too much (≥70% of sweat loss)

  • In ultras, sodium balance held unless high fluid + high sweat sodium combined

  • In a 5-hour heat trial, sodium boosted blood sodium but didn’t affect thirst, effort, or hydration

  • Most athletes naturally drink ~70% of what they sweat—no matter the sodium

  • Extra sodium didn’t reduce heat strain or improve body-water balance

  • Large sodium deficits were handled by the kidneys post-exercise, not mid-race

🛠️ Practical Applications

  • 🚫 Events under 4 hours ➔ No sodium needed, even in heat

  • 🍽️ “Salt to taste” ➔ Sufficient for most non-ultra athletes

  • ≥70% fluid + high sweat sodium ➔ Add sodium to avoid low plasma sodium

  • 🚫 <60% fluid replaced ➔ Sodium not needed, even in ultra events

  • 🍽️ Personalized sweat testing ➔ Helps fine-tune sodium plan for races over 6 hours

  • 🚫 Extra sodium ➔ No effect on thirst, fluid intake, or performance

  • 🚫 Cramps ➔ Sodium doesn’t prevent them in most runners

🎯 Bottom Line

  • Unless you're guzzling fluids and sweating salt, midrace sodium isn’t necessary

Don’t forget: You + Science = AWESOMENESS 😎

Yours in science,

Jonah

P.S. - We have a crew of 16,500+ nerds here who are running FAST using science.

Did you need running science advice or tips? 🏃‍♀️💨🧪

Reply with your question, Augie and I (pictured below) will get back to you with science-backed tips!

Enjoy the newsletter? Please forward to a pal. It only takes 18 seconds. Making this one took 11.23 hours.

Please email me directly if you’re interested in references for this week!